Six people were convicted on Thursday for gang-raping and murdering the 20-year-old girl while she was returning home from college in Kamduni village of North 24 Parganas district on June 7, 2013.
Observing that the case fell within the rarest of rare cases, Additional District and Sessions Judge Sanchita Sarkar pronounced capital punishment for Saiful Ali, Ansar Ali and Amin Ali who have been convicted of gang rape and murder.
Sheikh Emanul Islam, Aminur Islam and Bhola Naskar, who have been convicted on charges of gang rape, criminal conspiracy and causing disappearance of evidence, were sentenced to life imprisonment.
As soon as the news of the three getting death spread, the family of the victim as well Kamduni villagers broke into tears hailing the verdict.
While nine people were arrested and charged for the crime, the court on Thursday acquitted Rafiqul Islam and Nur Ali while the ninth accused Gopal Naskar died while the trial was on.
Even as he cried in joy, the victim’s brother said he will be meeting Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee seeking reversal of the acquittal of the two accused.
During the hearing for the quantum of punishment, the defence counsel contended that the case did not fall under the rarest of rare case and as such did not warrant death penalty. He cited several Supreme Court judgements arguing that convicts have not been awarded death penalty even in cases that were more heinous than the instant case.
Pointing to the severe injuries inflicted on the victim’s private parts, the prosecution pleaded for death penalty asserting that the convicts even after being convicted did not show repentance.
Rejecting the defence counsel’s arguments, the judge called out the names of each of the convicts as she pronounced the sentence.
The residents of Kamduni led by Tumpa Koyal and Moushumi Koyal who had formed a forum seeking death penalty for all the accused, hailed the verdict saying their fight for justice has been vindicated.
Alleging police slackness in the case, the forum members had knocked on the doors of top political and constitutional authorities including the president, demanding that the trial be expedited.
Police also drew flak after the victim’s uncle, a key witness in the case, succumbed to his injuries following a scuffle with security personnel during one of the protests in September 2013.
Street protests singed Kolkata and other parts of the state in the days and months after the Kamduni incident.
Women, youths, rights activists and college and school students, as well as leading lights of the civil society took out marches and rallies, and addressed meetings demanding justice and railing against what they called the “deteriorating law and order”.by Agencies.